I put 4 stars as I believe that the leather could have been a little thicker and soul a little more flexible as shoes should be. Aside from that, they are quite comfortable, no break in needed.I am 8-81/2, I ordered 8 and my feet are not the thinnest, yet they fit very well. so I would not necessarily go much lower nor upper in size.feel is nice, love the round toes shape, fits with everything, jeans, shorts, skirts, dress......They're comfy and sleek but fragile because it's soft leather. I love the way it looks.I really like these shoes, they are full uppers, and they are sewn not glued. I am a true woman’s 8 and I have a wider foot. The size 8 in these shoes is perfect with a little room past toes. If you have a medium to narrow foot you can size down, 1/2 size only. If you have a medium to wide foot, stick with your normal size. If you are between sizes then go down. That should be just about right. If you have wide (fat) toes then go up. Can’t get any more detailed then that! They are super cute.Sam Edelman did it again! This is the only brand that I trust! ❤️❤️❤️❤️